Small Orders
A small order is considered ordering up to 3 dozen. There is a 6-pack minimum for all orders.
Orders must be placed at least 48 hours in advance (larger orders may require more notice)
Local pick-up only (Branford & North Branford areas).
Complete payment online when selecting your purchase.
Cookies are packaged in boxes, unless otherwise noted.
Cancellations: 48+ hours’ notice for a refund; no refunds once baking begins.
For 6 packs, please choose 1 flavor. For dozens, you may choose up to 2 flavors.
Note: all cookies are made in a kitchen that uses nuts, dairy, wheat, soy, and eggs.
Large Orders/Catering
A large order is considered ordering 4 or more dozens.
For all large/catering orders, please email order@crumbcatchercookies.com to coordinate.
An inside look at how catering orders are prepared 🍪
From baking to packaging—designed for easy serving at meetings, events, and celebrations.
Catering Prices & Fees
(As of 5/6/26)
Regular Cookies
$5 for 1
$24 for 6
$45 for 12
Gluten-Free Cookies
$6 for 1
$30 for 6
$54 for 12
Individual Wrapping: Individually wrapped in cellophane and heat sealed - additional $0.50 per cookie.
Brownies
$5 for 1
$24 for 6
$45 for 12
Packaging Fees
Boxed Assortment - included in price, no additional fee
Individually wrapped - additional $0.50 per cookie
Boxed Assortment: Cookies placed in a box by flavor. No additional charge.
Gluten-Free Brownies
$6 for 1
$30 for 6
$54 for 12
Cookie Pops
$4 for 1
$22 for 6
$40 for 12
Delivery Fees
$10 delivery (local / within ~5 miles)
$15 delivery (5–10 miles)
$20+ delivery (10+ miles or large orders)
Contact Us
Have questions about your order? Let us know!